When one thinks about Kentucky, the image that often springs to mind is of sprawling horse farms, grand racehorses, and an unmistakable southern charm. However, if you dig deeper, you will find that nothing encapsulates the spirit of the Bluegrass State quite like bourbon. Growing up in Louisville during the vibrant 1970s and ’80s, it became apparent that there were three indispensable pillars of Kentucky life: the Kentucky Derby, college basketball, and, of course, bourbon.
But what happens when a Kentuckian moves beyond the state’s borders? For many, it becomes a stark realization that bourbon isn’t quite as well-loved in other regions. Often misunderstood and confused with other whiskies, the beloved spirit faced unfamiliarity in the broader American landscape. Thankfully, this perception has shifted dramatically over recent decades. Bourbon has made a triumphant return, captivating drinkers across the nation and the globe with its rich history and diverse flavor profiles.
In the present day, bourbon has transcended the confines of Kentucky, with distilleries springing up in nearly every corner of the United States. While purists may argue that true bourbon can only come from Kentucky—which produces a staggering 95% of the world’s supply—this notion is becoming increasingly outdated. Today, there are over 850 distilleries producing bourbon, offering a plethora of options for enthusiasts to explore.
Choosing the “best” bourbon, however, is no easy feat. That’s where various internationally recognized spirit competitions come into play. These contests rigorously evaluate bourbons from all over the world, offering a structured approach for consumers wanting to discover the standout bottles for their own collections.
The World Whiskies Awards, established by Whiskey Magazine in 2007, has quickly become the benchmark for quality bourbon evaluations. For 2024, they have crowned 1792 12-Year-Old as the World’s Best Bourbon. Distilled at the Barton Distillery in Bardstown, this small-batch bourbon has garnered praise for its harmonious blend of flavors, combining rich chocolate and caramel with a lingering hint of apricot. Such accolades underscore the exceptional craftsmanship that goes into creating a superior bourbon.
Meanwhile, the International Wine and Spirit Competition, a venerable institution founded in 1969, awarded its Bourbon Trophy for 2024 to the Kentucky Peerless Distilling Co.’s High Rye Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey. This particular bourbon incorporates a higher rye content in its mash bill, offering a unique spiciness that impressed judges. With rich baking spices and luscious fruit flavors intertwining, this bourbon is a testament to the innovation happening within the industry.
An equally insightful perspective on bourbon comes from those who work behind the bar. The Bartender Spirits Awards is a competition that highlights spirits readily available to consumers, recognizing the best options on the market today. The 2024 Bourbon of the Year was awarded to Varchas Reserve 102 Straight Bourbon Whiskey from Shankard Distillery in Michigan, achieving an impressive score of 97 out of 100. Judges raved about its complex palate, filled with notes of oranges, cinnamon, and chocolate, making it versatile for sipping neat or in cocktails.
Similarly, at the New York World Spirits Competition, Colonel E.H. Taylor Single Barrel Bourbon found its way to the top spot for the category of Best Single Barrel Bourbon – Up to 10 Years Old. Produced by the revered Buffalo Trace Distillery, this bourbon showcases a rich flavor profile that is hard to ignore, featuring notes of butterscotch and dried fruit.
The San Francisco World Spirits Competition, often regarded as the Oscars of the spirits world, has an adult equivalent of Hollywood’s nominees: Pure Antique 20-Year Straight Bourbon. This small-batch offering from a boutique preservation distillery in Bardstown stole the show in 2024, compelling judges with its blended notes of caramel, dark chocolate, and fruit.
The renaissance of bourbon is a remarkable journey—a celebrated return of a storied spirit. As the industry continues to flourish and innovate, it’s essential for enthusiasts and newcomers alike to keep an open mind and explore the tantalizing options available. This is more than just a drink; it’s a cultural emblem, a celebration of craftsmanship, and an evolving narrative that continues to entice and inspire. Whether you are a lifelong bourbon lover or just starting to sip, every bottle tells a story worth exploring.